Our History

The story of Presbyterians in Benalla is part of the much larger story of God’s work in the world. Since the beginning, God has been calling people to hear His promises, to repent and trust in Him, and to worship Him in spirit and in truth. The good news of salvation through faith in Jesus Christ is spreading around the world, and we continue to proclaim it to anyone who will listen.

The first known Presbyterian service in Benalla was conducted by Rev. James Nish of Sandhurst (now Bendigo) on a Sunday evening in May or June 1856, while travelling with his wife to open the Parish of Beechworth. According to a reminiscence published in the Benalla Standard on 31 October 1905, Mr Lowe, proprietor of the Benalla Hotel, suggested the service. The Church of England was made available, but heavy rain caused the river to rise, cutting off access between the two sides of town. A bellman announced the change of venue, and the congregation crowded into the hotel’s largest room, where Nish conducted worship and baptised seven or eight children.

Intermittent services in Benalla were conducted for a time by the Rev. J.K. McMillan, the minister of Beechworth from 1858.

Rev. Andrew Graham was appointed to minister to the Presbyterians in Longwood, Mansfield, Benalla, and Yarrawonga in 1859.

In 1862, Rev. Robert McCully represented the Parish of Benalla at the General Assembly, though official records of his call to Benalla are no longer discoverable. The first is the record of his induction as the Presbyterian minister for Benalla and Mansfield on 28th November, 1865. His induction service was held in the Benalla Courthouse (next to Holy Trinity Church of England) as the Presbyterian congregation did not yet have a building of its own.

In the early years, Benalla was linked with Mansfield and Euroa, and services were infrequent and irregular. The congregation met in a large room at the Commercial Hotel before obtaining the use of the Courthouse, where Rev. Robert McCully was inducted in November 1865. The congregation’s first elders were George Sharpe, MLA, John Sharp of Broken Creek, and Neil McMillan of Kilfeera. George Sharpe and William McKellar of Lima Station were among the first trustees and actively supported the construction of the original church through their efforts and generous giving.

Land in Benalla had been granted to the Church of England, Catholic, and Wesleyan churches in 1849. It was not until 1865 that land was granted to the Presbyterian Church on Barrack Street (now Church Street), at the northern end of Mair Street.

A small Neo-Gothic church was built in 1866. A manse was built next door in 1870 and a vestry was added to the church in 1871.

William McKellar, an early supporter of Presbyterian worship in the district, donated the church bell.

Rev. McCully was succeeded in 1868 by Rev. Alexander Murdoch, who ministered at Benalla until 1882. His charge initially covered an extensive district, including Dookie and the country along the Murray that later formed the Yarrawonga parish.

Rev. Alexander McConnan followed in 1884 and served the congregation until 1926. In 1887, the congregation adopted the name St. Andrew’s.

Just ten years into his ministry at Benalla, Rev. McConnan’s wife Harriet died in 1895, aged 36, four years after their son Archibald.

By 1901, the building could not accommodate the whole congregation, so Rev. McConnan oversaw the building of the present, larger church, designed by noted Melbourne architect Thomas Watts. The foundation stone was laid in May 1905, and the building was opened on 15th October of the same year, with three services being held.

The scattered nature of the parish made communication an important part of its ministry. In 1909, Rev. Alexander McConnan began a parish paper to keep members informed and strengthen their sense of belonging. It was particularly intended to maintain contact with families whose distance from Benalla prevented them from attending their parish church regularly.

The Fincham pipe organ was installed in the church in 1913 and enlarged the following year.

An honour roll was unveiled on 27th April 1919, recognising those who served in the Great War. Three of Rev. McConnan’s sons presented a pulpit chair, communion table and elders’ chairs in thanksgiving for their return from the war.

Women’s organisations played an important part in the congregation’s fellowship, fundraising and support for Christian missions. A branch of the Presbyterian Women’s Missionary Union was established on 25 August 1914, with Mrs Brown as its first president.

Alongside the women’s work, mission bands helped children and young people learn about and support the spread of the gospel overseas.

This interest also found expression in personal service: in 1949, Rita Munro left Benalla to train as a deaconess at Rolland House, Carlton, and subsequently served as a missionary in Korea.

Teaching children the Christian faith has been an important part of the congregation’s life since a Sunday school was established during Rev. Alexander Murdoch’s ministry in the 1870s.

By 1922, 122 children were attending Sunday school in the original church building, then known as St Andrew’s Hall. The growing need for accommodation led to the construction of the Kindergarten Hall in 1926, largely through the generosity of Mrs Isabel Say, widow of elder Victor Say.

The church became free of debt in 1945. The Kinder Hall was extended in 1947 as the congregation continued its work among children and families. Tennis and badminton brought members together, while a branch of the Presbyterian Fellowship of Australia began in 1945 with weekly meetings for young people.

Rev. McConnan and Dr. James A. D. Nish, a medical doctor and son of Rev. James Nish, advocated for the establishment of Benalla High School. When the school opened in 1912, it was temporarily accommodated in St. Andrew’s Hall (the original church building). Both men served as president of the High School Advisory Council, and their contribution was recognised when McConnan and Nish became two of the school’s house names in 1925.

After 42 years of ministry at Benalla, Rev. McConnan retired in 1926. Following his death, a set of three memorial windows commemorating his life and ministry were installed in the east transcept of the church in 1931. He was succeeded Rev. Frank Butchers.

More land was purchased in 1928 for a new manse, which was constructed in 1929 and occupied in 1930. Rev. Butchers remained until 1933 when he was called to Frankston.

Rev. Raymond Simons succeeded him in 1933 and remained until being called to Williamstown in 1944.

During the Second World War, the congregation offered practical hospitality to soldiers stationed in the district. From 1940 to 1945, the church hall was opened twice a week, providing a place for recreation, letter-writing and refreshments. Such activities were part of a wider pattern of service by the congregation’s women’s groups, which supported church work, missions and community organisations through fundraising and voluntary effort.

Rev. Alistair McLean ministered from 1944 until being called to Bacchus Marsh in 1961. During this time, around 400 children were regularly attending Sunday School each week. So the old manse was demolished (in 1957) to make way for the new hall, which was completed in 1958. The foundation stone was laid by the Moderator of the Presbyterian Church of Victoria, Rev. S. A. Goddard.

Rev. Ken Melville (previously a noted VFL footballer for Melbourne) came to Benalla in 1961 and remained until 1964, when he entered the Presbyterian Church of Victoria’s Department of Christian Education.

The parish’s ministry extended well beyond Benalla itself. At different times, ministers and lay preachers served congregations and preaching places at Baddaginnie, Goomalibee, Kilfeera, Winton and Warrenbayne. At Goomalibee, the Ballintine Memorial Church opened on 1st October 1955, supported by the generosity of the Ballintine family.

Changing circumstances gradually altered this network: the Kilfeera church was destroyed by fire that devastated the district on 6th February 1952. Services at Warrenbayne ceased in 1969, and the Goomalibee congregation closed in 2001.

In 1964, Rev. Stewart Chant was inducted. During his ministry, nationwide discussions were held regarding uniting with the Methodist and Congregational churches. In Benalla, combined services were held in June 1966, alternating between the Presbyterian and Methodist buildings.

When a formal vote was held in the 1970s, sufficient Presbyterians voted not to join the Uniting Church in Australia (which formed in 1977) for the property to be retained by the continuing congregation, though a significant number of members had joined the Uniting Church.

In 1977, the continuing Presbyterian congregations at Thoona and Balmattum joined the Benalla parish. Together with Benalla and Goomalibee, they formed a parish with four preaching places, served by its minister and a committed group of lay preachers.

Rev. Chant was instrumental in the continuing Presbyterian cause in the region, including assisting with the re-establishment of the Wangaratta Presbyterian Church.

In 1980, Rev. Chant retired to Queensland and was succeeded by Rev. Ken Martin in 1982, who was until then the pastor of Goulburn in New South Wales.

During the 1980s, outreach included “Barnarama” gospel meetings in Ian Sinclair’s shearing shed at Thoona. In 1988, members also participated in an interchurch effort to offer New Testaments to households throughout the district.

During Rev. Martin’s ministry, the Faith Mission Council was established to support mission work. After their time in Benalla was completed in 1989, Rev. and Mrs. Martin themselves went overseas as missionaries, going to Venda in South Africa.

Rev. Roy Taylor was called from Gisborne in 1991 with a desire to strengthen the church and connect more deeply with younger families. Over the next few years, he helped introduce more varied services and saw real growth, with younger members taking on responsibilities in preaching, worship, music, and children’s ministry. The 1993 Benalla flood stood out as one of the hardest times during his ministry. Rev. Taylor’s ministry at Benalla ended in 1997.

Rev. Dr. Dallas Clarnette succeeded him, initially as a temporary minister, and was inducted in 1999. In 2000, the parish hosted the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church of Victoria. Dr. Clarnette retired in 2004.

The following years included a series of temporary ministries, including by Rev. John Mercer and Mr. Peter Stanton.

In 2011, Rev. Ken Martin was again called as the minister of Benalla, bringing much-needed stability and pastoral care after a long vacancy. He retired in January 2016.

On 1st February 2016, Stephen McDonald was appointed as an exit student from the Presbyterian Theological College in Melbourne. He was ordained and inducted as the minister of the parish on 31st December 2016.